/ articles for review

Yosef Story Echoes at Purim

Descendants of Rachel - Yosef her son, and Mordechai from the tribe of Binyamin - become Jews who rise to power in a foreign land and use their position to save their families or people

By BARUCH FRYDMAN-KOHL
 
Descendants of Rachel – Yosef her son, and Mordechai from the tribe of Binyamin – become Jews who rise to power in a foreign land and use their position to save their families or people.
 
Advice and appointment  
  • Esther 2:3-4: Let the king appoint officers throughout all of the states of his kingdom, and let them gather every young virgin…and this was good in the eyes of the king and he did so.
  • Breishit 41:34-37: Let the king appoint officers on the land…and they will collect all of the produce…and this found favor in the eyes of Pharaoh.  

Physical appearance  
  • Esther 2:7: Esther was beautiful in stature and appearance.
  • Breishit 39:6: Yosef was beautiful in stature and appearance.  
Favorites  
  • Esther 2:17: And the king loved Esther more than all of the other women and she found favor in his eyes more than the other virgins.
  • Breishit 37:3-4: And Yisrael loved Yosef more than all of his brothersand Yosef found favor in his eyes.  
Anger and Plotting  
  • Esther 2.21: In those days, when Mordechai was sitting in the gate of the king, Bigtan and Teresh, two of the eunuchs of the king, guardians of the entrance, became angry and plotted to attack the king.
  • Breishit 41.10: Pharaoh became angry at his servants and placed me under guard in the commissary, I and the chief baker.  
Memory  
  • Esther 2.23: [His deeds] were written in the chronicles of the king. …. (6.1)That night, the sleep of the king was disturbed and he asked that the memory book (sefer hazikhronot), the chronicles, be brought to him
  • Breishit 40.23: And the chief butler did not remember (lo zakhar) Yosef and he forgot him…. (41.9) The chief butler said to Pharaoh: "I remember my sins today"  
Yada, yada, yada  
  • Esther 3.4: And they would address [Mordechai] day after day, but he did not heed them
  • Breishit 39.10: And she would speak to Yosef day after day, but he did not heed her
Authority  
  • Esther 3.10: The king removed his ring from his hand
  • Breishit 41.42: Pharoah removed his ring from his hand and placed it on the hand of Yosef  
Anguish  
  • Esther 4.1: Mordechai tore his garments
  • Breishit 37.29: [Reuven] tore his garments  
Double Despair  
  • Esther 4:16: Go and gather all the Jews…Thus I shall present myself before the king, not in accordance with custom, and if I shall be lost, then I shall be lost.
  • Breishit 43:14   May the Eternal God show compassion… but if I will be left childless, I will be left childless.  
Parades  
  • Esther 6.11: Haman took the clothing and the horse, dressed Mordechai and escorted him through the streets of the city calling out before him
  • Breishit 41:43: He escorted him … and called out before him  
Themes
  • Jews who rise to power in a foreign land and use their position to save their families or people.
  • Descendants of Rachel – Yosef her son, and Mordechai from the tribe of Binyamin.
  • The cure precedes the illness: Yosef is in position before the famine begins. Esther becomes queen and Mordechai saves the king before the ascent of Haman.
  • The Yosef story reaches a climax when Yehuda approaches him and pleads on behalf of Binyamin. The megillah turns when Esther approaches Ahashverosh at the risk of her life.
  • The revealing of character: Yosef to his brothers and Haman to Ahashverosh.
  • Discovery of sexual overtures/intrigue from Mrs. Potifar to Yosef and from Haman toward Esther.
  • Yosef brings his family to Pharaoh, who grants them land. Esther reveals her relationship to Mordechai and Ahashverosh places Mordechai in charge.
  • The story of Yosef tells about the economic plan and the megillah tells us that Ahashverosh placed a tax on the lands he controlled.
  • Each narratives feature reversals when the king cannot sleep.
  • Each narrative has a recurring event which moves the story forward: the dreams of Yosef and Pharaoh and the parties of Ahashverosh involving Vashti and Esther.
  • The role of God is not overt in either narrative.
  • The Yosef narrative leads into servitude and ultimate redemption.
  • The Esther story leads to power but in unredeemed exile, perhaps hinting at a hoped for future redemption.
Baruch Frydman-Kohl is Senior Rabbi at Beth Tzedec Congregation in Toronto, Canada, and a graduate of the Shalom Hartman Institute Rabbinic Leadership Initiative . This article is based on a shiur he gave at the Rabbi Benjamin Hollander Shloshim Memorial

You care about Israel, peoplehood, and vibrant, ethical Jewish communities. We do too.

Join our email list for more Hartman ideas

Search
FOLLOW HARTMAN INSTITUTE
Join our email list

SEND BY EMAIL

The End of Policy Substance in Israel Politics